Rethinking Discipline, Strengthening Communities

Introduction

Traditional school discipline has been centered around punitive measures—detentions, suspensions, and even expulsions for decades. While these methods may seem effective in maintaining order, research shows they often fail to address the root causes of student behavior, disproportionately affect marginalized students, and lead to lower graduation rates.

Enter restorative practices, a transformative approach that shifts the focus from punishment to repairing harm, fostering accountability, and building community. Schools implementing restorative practices see reduced conflict, improved relationships, and a stronger school culture where students feel valued and heard.

Why Traditional Discipline Falls Short

Zero-tolerance policies and exclusionary discipline create a cycle of punishment that often leaves students disengaged, alienated, and more likely to re-offend. Consider the following issues with punitive discipline:

🔴 It doesn’t address the root cause of behavior – When a student acts out, punishment rarely explores why the behavior occurred. Instead of helping students develop better coping skills, it removes them from the environment.

🔴 It disproportionately affects students of color and students with disabilities – Studies have found that Black students are more likely to be suspended or expelled than their white peers for the same offenses, contributing to the school-to-prison pipeline.

🔴 It creates disconnection – Students who are suspended or expelled feel excluded from their school community. This disconnection makes them more likely to disengage academically and socially.

🔴 It doesn’t teach accountability – Traditional discipline focuses on enforcing consequences rather than helping students understand the impact of their actions on others.

What Are Restorative Practices?

Restorative practices focus on building relationships, preventing conflict, and resolving harm through meaningful dialogue rather than punishment. Instead of asking, “What rule was broken, and what is the punishment?” restorative approaches ask:

• What happened?

• Who was affected?

• How can we repair the harm?

This method encourages students to take responsibility for their actions, make amends, and learn how to resolve conflicts constructively.

Core Principles of Restorative Practices

Restorative practices rest on three foundational pillars:

1️⃣ Building a Strong Community – A school culture that fosters relationships and trust leads to fewer conflicts and better communication.
2️⃣ Repairing Harm, Not Just Punishing – Restorative methods focus on acknowledging harm, making amends, and restoring relationships.
3️⃣ Reintegrating, Not Excluding – Instead of pushing students away, restorative practices help them reconnect with their community.

Key Restorative Strategies in Schools

✅ Restorative Circles

Restorative circles are structured conversations that allow students and teachers to discuss emotions, concerns, and conflicts. These circles help prevent issues from escalating and create a safe space for honest dialogue.

Types of restorative circles include:

• Community-Building Circles – These are used proactively to develop relationships and create a sense of belonging.

• Conflict Resolution Circles – Help students address and resolve conflicts in a structured, respectful manner.

• Reintegration Circles – Help students return to the classroom after a suspension or disciplinary action.

✅ Restorative Conversations & Conferences

When harm has been done, a restorative conversation between the affected parties helps address the issue in a way that promotes understanding and accountability. These conversations include:

• Acknowledging what happened

• Expressing how it impacted others

• Collaborating on a way to repair the harm

✅ Peer Mediation Programs

Students often feel more comfortable resolving conflicts with the help of their peers rather than authority figures. Peer mediation trains students to facilitate restorative conversations, helping their classmates resolve disputes peacefully.

✅ Community Agreements

Community agreements involve students in setting expectations for behavior rather than enforcing rules from the top down. When students take part in shaping the guidelines, they feel more invested in upholding them.

✅ Restorative Re-entry Plans

When students return from suspension or an extended absence, schools can support them through re-entry meetings that reintegrate them into the school community and provide them with a plan for success.

How Restorative Practices Benefit Schools

📉 Reduces Suspensions & Expulsions – Schools that implement restorative justice see a significant drop in disciplinary actions, keeping students engaged in class.

🤝 Improves Student-Teacher Relationships – When educators take a restorative approach, students feel heard and respected, leading to stronger relationships and higher academic engagement.

🛑 Breaks the School-to-Prison Pipeline – Replacing punitive discipline with constructive interventions restorative practices help keep students in school and out of the criminal justice system.

🎯 Teaches Social-Emotional Skills – Restorative practices help students develop empathy, communication, conflict resolution, and accountability—skills that benefit them for life.

How to Implement Restorative Practices in Your School

1️⃣ Educate Staff & Students – Train teachers, administrators, and students in restorative techniques. Professional development workshops and peer-led training can help integrate these methods effectively.

2️⃣ . Start Small and Scale Up—Before implementing school-wide changes, Begin with restorative circles in advisory periods or small groups.

3️⃣ Integrate Restorative Language – Shift from punitive phrases like “You broke the rule” to restorative ones like “How did this impact others?”.

4️⃣ . Use Restorative Practices in Daily Routines—These approaches should not just be used for discipline but should also be part of everyday classroom interactions.

5️⃣ . Involve Families and the Community—Engage parents, guardians, and community members to ensure a consistent approach to conflict resolution.

Final Thoughts

Restorative practices aren’t just about discipline—they’re about creating a school culture where every student feels valued, supported, and responsible for their actions.

By prioritizing relationships, fostering accountability, and focusing on healing rather than punishment, schools can transform into places where students thrive socially, emotionally, and academically.

Want to learn more or bring restorative practices to your school? Let’s start the conversation today!

🔗 Sign up now to get training!

#RestorativeJustice #EducationReform #StrongerSchools #BetterDiscipline